How to Critique Your Own Song Writing: 10 Steps


If you’ve created something as magical as your own song, don’t you owe it yourself to make it the best it can be? We writers have to edit and revise every story (every word, every comma, every period), and believe me, it’s worth it. Polishing a piece gives you an opportunity to take some good and make it shine.

song critiqueSongwriter Cliff Goldmacher is a producer, session musician, engineer, and owner of recording studios in Nashville, TN, and Sonoma, CA. Here are his top ten questions to ask yourself about your song, in order to make both the lyrics and melody strong. Many of the items on this checklist are very similar to editing fiction. Have fun!

Here’s Cliff Goldmacher’s advice:

1. Do you have a strong opening line?
The opening line of your song is the first and best chance to engage your listener in the story you’re about to tell. Strong opening lines explain the where, what, and who of your story and will eventually lead to the “why” the story is being told. Make sure your opening line is designed to start your listener down the road to getting involved in the story you’re telling.

2. Imagery and Metaphor.
One of the best ways to put a listener immediately into the middle of your song’s story is to use strong imagery. I’ve also heard this imagery called “furniture.” These images are the details in a lyric that give your listener things to remember and connect with. Generally speaking, imagery is reserved for the verses where the meat of your story is being told. Choruses are designed to state the main point or theme of your song. Another way to think about imagery is to “show ‘em, not tell ‘em.” What that means is that it’s less effective to say, for example, “she was a seductive woman but she was bad news” than it is to describe her as “a black heart in a green dress.”

3. Are your lyrics singable?
Be sure the words you use are easy to sing and phrased naturally, making sure your lyric is “conversational.” Lyrics that are awkward or emphasize the wrong syllables pull a listener’s ear in a bad way. There’s a reason the word “baby” is in almost every song ever written; those long “a” and “e” sounds are easy to sing.

4. How effective is your hook?
The main point and identifier of your song can be referred to as the hook. It is the part of the lyric that reaches out and grabs the listener. Make sure that along with the story you’re telling, the hook is clear and doing its job. Often the lyrical hook of the song is also its title. It’s that important.

5. Does your chorus have a strong last line?
There are very few places in a song’s lyric more important than the last line of the chorus. This is the place where everything you’ve been leading up to in your verses and the first lines of your chorus pays off. It’s often the place where the hook is found, and usually leaves the listener satisfied that they understand your message. One important way to make the last line of your chorus count is to set it up with some kind of rhyme in one of the earlier chorus lines. That way, not only are the words important but they complete a rhyme, which adds extra emphasis.

6. Does the overall idea of your song work?
Often when we’ve worked on a lyric for a long time, we get so wrapped up in making things rhyme and using imagery that the overall concept of the song loses some of its focus. After you’ve finished your lyric, be sure the overall message of the song is developed and supported in every line. While you, the songwriter, already know your song’s story, you need to make doubly sure that a listener who is hearing your song for the first time will know what you’re talking about.

7. Is your verse melody interesting?
Given that the melody of your song is one of the first things people hear and pay attention to, you’ll want to be sure that your verse melody is catchy and unique. This doesn’t mean your melody should be bizarre or uncomfortable but rather it should be distinctive and memorable.

8. Does your chorus melody differ from your verse melody?
So much of what we do as songwriters is about giving the listener clues as to what the most important parts of our songs are. By making sure that your chorus melody is not only strong but differentiates itself from the verse melody, you’ll cue the listener in to the fact that you’ve arrived at the main musical – and lyrical – moment in the song.

9. Does your bridge add to the song?
A bridge is designed as a moment in the song where you step away from the verses and choruses to make an additional lyrical observation or melodic contribution. If your bridge melody sounds too much like your verse or chorus, even if the lyric is doing something new, the risk is that you’ll miss an opportunity to add something of value to an already strong song. Be sure that if you have a bridge, it’s musically apart from what you’ve been doing in your song’s other sections.

10. Does your melody flow naturally throughout the song?
Not only should the melody in each section of your song distinguish itself, but your overall melody should flow naturally from section to section. Be careful not to have a melody that is too repetitive. A little repetition is a good thing as it adds to the “hooky” nature of your song, but too much repetition becomes distracting and a bit unpleasant from the listener’s standpoint. Allow your melody to sit comfortably over the chords you’ve chosen. The harmonic – chordal – decisions you make can serve to either accentuate or hinder your melodic work.

Critiquing your own songs is often a time-consuming and somewhat frustrating experience. That said, it’s essential that you hold your songs up to the highest standard if you’re hoping to have a better chance at commercial success. I do want to remind you, however, that your first – and most important – job is to write the song. Focusing on critiquing your song too early in the process might prevent you from writing something heartfelt and spontaneous. In my experience, it’s always easier to get it all out first and invite your “editor” to the party once you’re done.

Good luck!

Cliff Goldmacher‘s website,, is full of resources for the aspiring songwriter, including monthly online webinars. Go to for the latest schedule. Cliff’s company,, provides songwriters outside of Nashville with virtual access to Nashville’s best session musicians and singers for their songwriting demos.

You can download a FREE sample of Cliff’s eBook “The Songwriter’s Guide To Recording Professional Demos” by going to

Contact Cliff on Facebook:, or Twitter: @edusongwriter


Stay in touch! Subscribe to this blog or chat with author Rebecca Laclair on Twitter at @WriterRLaclair. Looking for fun graphics and free memes? Visit the official RADIO HEAD Pinterest pageJoin my Book Review Team!


What's on your mind?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s